Note: All fields are required.

 I have read and understand the Disclaimer.

from our blog

August 29, 2017

The Insurance Industry Quick-Hit Settlement

If you’ve been in a collision and it was someone else’s fault, odds are very good that you will hear from the at-fault driver’s insurance company as soon as possible. It’s a tactic that is happening more and more in Arizona. This is done for a variety of reasons: (1) the insurance company would like […]


Allstate Taking $50,000 Bad Faith Claim to Supreme Court

An interesting case has taken place in Pennsylvania, where an individual transferred his rights in a bad faith claim against an insurance company to another individual. As the claim was against Allstate, it is fighting accountability, saying that the allowance for bad faith claims to be assigned in such manner has the potential to create windfalls for plaintiffs. In actuality, it simply gets the injury fully compensated and discourages insurance companies, like Allstate, from making low-ball, absurd offers and forcing injury victims into litigation.

All of this is a result of an accident which occurred in 2007. Jared Wolfe suffered soft tissue damage in an accident when another individual, under the influence of drugs and alcohol, struck his car. The individual driving was insured by Allstate for a $50,000 limit.

Wolfe requested $25,000 in damages to cover his medical costs (well within Allstate’s policy limits), but Allstate refused and counter-offered $1,200. Wolfe filed a suit against the driver for damages. After hearing the evidence, the  jury awarded him $15,000 in compensatory and $50,000 in punitive damages. Allstate paid the $15k, but refused to pay the $50,000 because the driver’s policy does not cover punitive damages. In other words, Allstate completely ignored what was in its insured’s best interest when it forced this claim into litigation.

The driver assigned all his rights in the matter over to Wolfe, who was then able to file an insurance bad faith claim against Allstate. After hearing the evidence, the jury in the new case again awarded Wolfe the $50,000 award. Allstate in true “Delay, Deny, Defend” form of course appealed. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court will determine if such an assignment is allowed under Pennsylvania law.

Allstate is arguing that allowing anyone other than the policyholder to file an insurance bad faith claim will start to shift towards “overcompensating” for injuries. Allstate’s protestations ring a little hollow when you consider the details of the current case. Allstate is refusing to pay out an amount that was within the policyholder’s original limits; which was twice awarded to the injured party by two separate juries. It is difficult to see how Allstate can make its argument with a straight face. Allstate completely ignored what was in the best interest of its insured, i.e., Allstate’s insured faced punitive damages for driving under the influence, when it made a low-ball offer of $1,200 to an injury victim with a legitimate claim. Allstate also ignored an offer that was half of its insured’s policy limits. After all these years and the “outing” of its McKinsey documents, Allstate amazingly continues to follow its corporate policy of “profit over people.” Fairly compensating injury victims and taking into consideration what is in the best interest of the insured over Allstate making money is not “overcompensating injured plaintiffs.” It is doing what Allstate should have done in the first place.

If you ever have issues or problems dealing with insurance companies, do not hesitate to get in touch with a skilled insurance bad faith attorney today.


Comments Off on Allstate Taking $50,000 Bad Faith Claim to Supreme Court

Comments are closed.

  • Shane Harward Law Offices of Shane L. Harward PLC

    10575 North 114th Street
    Suite 103
    Scottsdale, Arizona 85259

    Telephone 480-874-2918
    Facsimile 480-588-5063

    By Appointment Only:
    4809 East Thistle Landing Drive
    Suite 100
    Phoenix, Arizona 85044

    Telephone 602-384-4638

    Mailing Address:
    Post Office Box 12877
    Scottsdale, Arizona 85267