Note: All fields are required.

 I have read and understand the Disclaimer.

from our blog

August 3, 2014

Allstate Taking $50,000 Bad Faith Claim to Supreme Court

An interesting case has taken place in Pennsylvania, where an individual transferred his rights in a bad faith claim against an insurance company to another individual. As the claim was against Allstate, it is fighting accountability, saying that the allowance for bad faith claims to be assigned in such manner has the potential to create windfalls for […]


Federal Court Says Bad Faith Insurance Denial Can be Brought Against Insurance Adjuster

A recent federal district court case tackled the issue of whether an Arizona insurance adjuster may be personally sued for bad faith insurance claim denial.

The case started on March 4, 2011 when Frank Gambrell collided with another vehicle on an Arizona freeway. Gambrell sustained serious injuries in the accident; his medical expenses totaled more than $87,000 and he lost more than $6,000 in wages from not being able to work. Gambrell filed a claim under multiple insurers, all of which accepted his claim except for his own personal auto insurer, IDS Property Casualty Insurance Co. After requesting reconsideration and being denied twice, Gambrell brought a lawsuit alleging bad faith denial of insurance coverage and breach of contract. Gambrell sued both IDS and the claims adjuster assigned to the case, Stacey Harrish. The defendants moved to dismiss the portion of the lawsuit against Harrish because it argued that the insurance adjuster could not be sued for a breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing.

Judge John W. Sedwick of the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona ruled that Arizona law does not clearly allow or prevent an insured from bringing a claim for bad faith denial of insurance coverage. The judge noted that bad faith denial claims are based on the terms of an insurance contract to which only the insurer and insured are parties. However, the court noted that the Arizona Court of Appeals has held that the insurer and agent (the claims adjuster) are “engaged in a joint venture” which binds the adjuster to the same duties owed by the insurer. This case is helpful for policyholders because it potentially allows insureds to avoid diversity jurisdiction if the insurance claim adjuster is a citizen of Arizona and thus eliminates insurance carriers’ ability to remove bad faith lawsuits to the federal court system.

The case is IDS Property Casualty Insurance Co. v.  Gambrell, Docket Number 2:12-cv-01227 .

Comments Off

Comments are closed.

  • Shane Harward Law Offices of Shane L. Harward PLC

    10575 North 114th Street
    Suite 103
    Scottsdale, Arizona 85259

    Telephone 480-874-2918
    Facsimile 480-588-5063

    By Appointment Only:
    4809 East Thistle Landing Drive
    Suite 100
    Phoenix, Arizona 85044

    Telephone 602-384-4638

    Mailing Address:
    Post Office Box 12877
    Scottsdale, Arizona 85267